This rule applies in the field of play, at the sideline, and in the end zone. Rule 4 ball in play, dead ball, out of bounds rule 5 series of downs, line to gain rule 6 kicks. Side judge keith washington holds a flag but doesnt throw it on a play late in the fourth quarter of the game between the seattle seahawks and the detroit lions that was ruled a touchback after lions wide receiver calvin johnson fumbled and the ball was batted out of bounds in the end zone, monday, oct. Oct 17, 2017 so pats fans are all happy this rule exists, and it seems to have been properly applied in sundays win against the jets the rule basically states that if a team fumbles the ball into and out of the endzone over the side line or the end line that its a touchback and the other team takes. As it turns out, and nfl vp of officiating dean blandino later confirmed, it was actually an illegal play and should have been called illegal batting. In rugby it makes sense because a lose ball that goes oob is restarted where it went oob, but since that isnt true in the nfl, the rule is illogical but has never been changed. The kicking team may not kick the ball out of bounds or be the last to touch the ball before it goes out of bounds between the goal lines. I mishandled the hand off, better boot the ball into the end zone. When a free kick untouched by team b touches the ground on or behind team bs goal line, the ball becomes dead and belongs to team b. A bat is the intentional striking of the ball with any part of the hand or arm. Wright got in on the action and swatted the ball out the back of the endzone to make. Nfl sticking up for your teammate moments part 2 youtube. Beginners guide to football nfl rules the football girl.
As blandino explained, the nfl rule book outlines the illegality of the batted ball. If the action occurs in the opponents end zone, it is a touchdown or a touchback. Nfl will continue to discuss the worst rule in football. Detroit lions should have had the ball despite fumble. There was no touchback since it was the bears fumble that put the ball into the end zone, so the impetus rule goes into effect. Before 2015, the only scenario in which a onepoint safety could have been scored in the nfl would have involved, on a conversion attempt in which the ball was not kicked by the offense, the defense then kicking or batting a loose ball out of its own end zone without taking possession of the ball, giving the offense a onepoint safety. Nfl batted ball rule explainer referees conferred after seattles k. Ncaa rule 9 conduct of players and others subject to the rules. So if a team provides the impetus that puts a ball into their opponents end zone.
When a player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward. If the ball goes out of bounds in the end zone without the offense possessing it in the end zone, the ball belongs to the defense. As soon as wright bats the ball out of bounds, he throws his arms in the air and looks over at an official. While learning nfl rules may take some time, knowing the basic football rules can dramatically increase ones enjoyment of the game.
It is also a fumble if the action occurs in the end zone of the player who caught the loose ball. The fumble into end zone touchback rule discussion in. This no souvenirs rule was in place so that the aaf would not lose possession of the electronic tracking apparatus embedded in each ball. Nfl not considering rule change on fumbles through the end. This edition of the official playing rules of the national football league contains all current rules governing the playing of professional football that are in effect for the 2019 nfl season. Oct 01, 2015 i know youre joking even thought there was no boogie nights reference, but for a kid out of college with a photographic memory who doesnt want to go to 3 years of law school, it wouldnt be a bad gig to watch games from a box with the rule book in his lap and buzz down any time something was overlooked or improperly applied. Oct 06, 2015 thats why pete carroll didnt know the rule since ive never seen it called for hitting it backwards out of the endzone including the multiple times that a punter has knocked the ball out. In addition to barring players from batting the ball out of the end zone, the rule also makes it a penalty to bat a loose ball toward the opposing end zone as seahawks safety chris maragos did.
Why not rule it as down at the spot of the fumble, or at worst place it on the 25 yard line with no change of possession. Rule 12 player conduct section 1 blocking, use of hands, arms, and body legal and illegal block article 1 a player of either team may block obstruct or impede an opponent at any time, provided that. A special rule applies in college football and the nfl with regard to field goal attempts. Rule 8 forward pass, backward pass, fumble section 1 forward pass definition article 1 definition it is a forward pass if. How nfl coaches are outsmarting the rule book more often than ever the nfl s rule book is complexsometimes too complexbut the leagues best coaches have learned how to. If a kickedoff ball goes into the end zone and then is recovered by a member of. I suspect that there was once a time that fumbles out of the sidelines were spotted at the spot that the ball went out these days.
I do not own the music and the footage used in this video. If a fumble in the endzone rolls out of bounds, is it a. It does not include catching or batting the ball before it reaches the receiver. Mar 17, 2017 batting the ball out of the end zone intentionally is a violation of the rules, but the referees, particularly back judge greg wilson, believed the play by wright was unintentional. So of course he talked at length on how he teaches the patriots the rule book. Oct 18, 2009 if a fumble in the endzone rolls out of bounds, is it a touchdown. Calvin johnson is responsible for putting the ball in the end zone via fumble, so they are penalized with a touchback. By rule, a fumble that goes out of bounds through a defensive teams end zone is a touchback, and the defensive team gets the ball. Fans witnessed examples of the two worst rules in the nfl the unexplainable catch rule and unjustifiably ridiculous endzone out of bounds turnovertouchback. This edition of the official playing rules of the national football league contains all current rules governing the playing of professional football that are in effect for the 2017 nfl season. The patriots had the ball on 2ndand7 at the miami 23. The tv coverage pointed out an interesting wrinkle. However, the nfl has a clear rule about batting in the end zone. Wright and back judge greg wilson, football fans now know all about the obscure nfl rule.
Nfl implements huge new touchback rule, admits it could. Member clubs of the league may amend the rules from time to time, pursuant to the applicable voting procedures of the nfl constitution and bylaws. The seahawks beat the lions on monday night football football thanks to a goal line forced fumble that was batted out of the end zone by. The rule book is actually very simple in this regard. Wright admits to illegal bat, says he didnt know rule. It was never intended to pure a punitive measure to punish people trying to stretch out at the goalline. No penalties were called and a touchback was called, awarding the ball to the seahawks on their own 20yard line. If the receiving team is the last to touch the ball before it goes out of bounds, the receiving team puts the ball in play at the inbounds spot. Nfl official explains why one of footballs worst rules.
If a punt goes out of bounds it is given to the other team where it went out and if it goes untouched into the endzone it is put on the 20yd line and the other team takes over. Five ways to fix the dumbest rule in football the ringer. Mar 23, 2018 the rule that says a fumble into the end zone and out of bounds goes to the defense on the 20yard line seems illogical. If a scrimmage kick goes out of bounds between the goal lines or comes to rest inbounds and no player attempts to secure it, the ball becomes dead and belongs to the receiving team at the dead ball spot exception. By rule, if the defensive player batted the ball out of. In the nfl, if the ball is fumbled out the back of the. A player may not bat or punch a a loose ball in field of play toward opponents goal line. A defender pushes him and the ball pops out into the endzone and rolls out of bounds. A fumble going out ofbounds in the endzone being defended is ruled a safety if the offensive team forced the ball into the endzone. If the action occurs in the opponents end zone, it. Where the word illegal appears in this rule book, it is an institutional term of art. In all cases, a fumble recovered by an out ofbounds player is considered an out ofbounds fumble even if the ball never leaves the field of play. Seahawks safety kam chancellor knocked the ball out of johnsons hands, coming out inside the 1, just before johnson crossed into. How to fix the dumbest rule in college football calling a touchback when an player fumbles the ball out of the end zone is utterly ridiculous.
Oct 05, 2015 referees screw up crucial call at end of lionsseahawks. The fumble into end zone touchback rule green bay packers. I would support such a compromise rule, as it still rewards the defense for causing a fumble but not to the extent that the present rule does. And if the ball gets out of bounds through the end zone then it is a touchback. Whats the justification for this rarelyinvoked nfl fumble rule. Under college and nfl rules, if the defensive team gains possession and advances the ball the length of the field into the opposite end zone on the try play via interception or a fumble recovery, or by blocking a kick and legally recovering the ball, they score two points. J wright batted calvin johnsons fumble out of the end zone. While the ball is in the air over the end zone, a81, who is either on the oneyard line or in the end zone, bats the ball into the field of play. When an nfl player fumbles the ball out of bounds through the end zone. No player shall bat other loose balls forward in the field of play or in any direction if the. Plus there is illegal batting which would be a penalty if you kicked the ball into the endzone on purpose. In american and canadian gridiron football, pass interference pi is a foul that occurs when a.
Bill belichick loves to show how much smarter he is than you. The rule found in rule 12, section 4, article 1 of the nfl rule book prohibits players from batting the ball forward on the field of play and in any direction while in the end zone. Any player may block a scrimmage kick in the field of play or the end zone. When a ball becomes dead in the endzone and its not a touchdown, the team who is responsible for putting the ball in the endzone is penalized. This week, the unusual call was illegal batting, as the nfl. If the runner steps out at the 1 inch line and the ball has not crossed the plane of the end zone then it is not a td. Nfl vp of officiating dean blandino weighs in on if there should have been a penalty on seattle after k. Movement of the ball does not automatically result in loss of control.
Nfl has some littleknown rules and regulations ap thanks to seattle linebacker k. A fumble in gridiron football occurs when a player who has possession and control of the ball loses it before being downed tackled, scoring, or going out of bounds. Rule 12, section 4, article 1 of the nfl rulebook defines an illegal bat. Referees screw up crucial call at end of lionsseahawks. Since batting the ball out of bounds is a penalty, the enforcement is at the spot of the fumble in this case. Nfls blandino explains why batted ball was a penalty. Even steve young and ray were like uh what are you talking about. Beginners guide to football learning nfl rules if you are a football beginner, one of your biggest obstacles to achieving full enjoyment of the game is likely understanding football rules. In the national football league nfl, the rule is that there can be no pass interference at or behind the line of scrimmage. But what is the purpose of having a fumble out of the opponents endzone be ruled as a touchback and change of possession. Nov, 2017 dont know what fox has to do with it but the rule is fine in my opinion. Nfl implements huge new touchback rule, admits it could backfire the nfl isnt exactly sure if its new touchback rule is a good idea or not. For more than 11 players on the field of play or the end zone while the ball is in play.
Oct 15, 2017 but the play exposed a part of the nfl rule book that could use revision. Player out of bounds a team a player who goes out of bounds during a free kick down may not return inbounds during the down exception. Wrights act of tapping the ball out of bounds is known as an illegal bat. B1 kicks, bats, or muffs the loose ball new impetus on his twoyard line and it goes out of bounds behind the goal line. A defensive player may use his hands, arms, or body to push, pull. A full breakdown of the missed batting call pride of detroit. It is also a fumble if the action occurs in the end zone of the player who. The ball is dead as soon as its failure as a kick to score a try is evident.
Rule 12, section 4, article 1b applies the term illegal bat when any player bats or punches a loose ball that has touched the ground in any direction, if it is in either end zone. The nfl s rule book says that a player has possession if he has a firm grip and control of the ball with his hands or arms, and for a second there, seferianjenkins clearly did not have a. For enforcement, treat as a foul during a backward pass or fumble. The worst rule in the nfl nearly broke the saints road to. If you fumble out of your own endzone, sure, that should be a safety. Its time to talk about the nfls dumb fumble touchback. Out of bounds between goal lines or at rest inbounds article 7. Illegally kicking ball article 9 no player may deliberately kick any loose ball or ball in players possession.
If a team has more than 11 players on the field of play or the end zone when a snap, free kick, or faircatch kick is made, the ball is in play, and it is a foul. In last nights case, seattle gets the ball as a turnover. Seconds after the fumble, seattle seahawks linebacker k. Another example of nfl rule book becoming so dense and so complicated that even people in charge of calling game dont fully know the rules. Jan 23, 2011 if a punt goes out of bounds it is given to the other team where it went out and if it goes untouched into the endzone it is put on the 20yd line and the other team takes over. Oct 06, 2015 wright admits to illegal bat, says he didnt know rule. Why is a fumble that goes out of bounds on the sideline return to the fumbling team, but a fumble that goes into the end zone get considered a touchback. Many fans are calling for changes, but which one should be overhauled first. If any player fumbles after the twominute warning in a half, only the fumbling player is permitted to recover andor advance the ball. This is also required for a player attempting to make a catch at the sideline and going to the ground out of bounds.
If it was treated like a normal outofbounds fumble, the only way you could get a td for fumbling into the end would be if you fumbled into the endzone and then recovered it in the endzone. I believe the difference in the two situations comes from seattle being on defense and kj wright batting the ball to force a touchback compared to a kicker batting kicking the ball out of the endzone on a bad snap to avoid the return team recovering it for a touchdwon. Yardage accumulated to advance the ball out of the end zone is added to the yardage accumulated beyond the goal line to make up the total fumble return yardage. Clarified example d under general principles of scoring yardage on fumble plays, the act of a defensive player forcing a fumble does not constitute touching batting of a fumbled ball. It is not meant to connote illegality under any public law. May 24, 2017 nfl loosens rules on end zone celebrations after touchdowns the nfl announced on tuesday it is relaxing its rules on celebrations in the end zone after big plays. Bill belichick talks at length how he teaches patriots the. If the runner goes into the end zone before going out of bounds then the ball is in play and it is a td. Another problem with the present rule is that a crafty defender can get away with intentionally knocking. Referees miss illegal batting play at end of seahawks. If the result of the free kick is a touchback rule 86 for team b, they will put the ball in play at their 25yard line. By rule, a fumble that goes out of bounds through a defensive teams end zone. By rule, it is any act other than passing, kicking, punting, or successful handing that results in loss of player possession. Nov 15, 2017 five ways to fix the dumbest rule in football when an nfl player fumbles the ball out of bounds through the end zone, it automatically results in a touchback.
Wright pursued the ball into the end zone, where he tapped the ball out of bounds for a touchback. The nfls convoluted rules cost the jets a touchdown, and maybe a win. Wright not kam chancellor batting the ball out of the end zone and officials failing to throw their flags, but the reality is johnson would have scored if he did not drop it and. In american football, a touchback is a ruling which is made and signaled by an official when the. Serious question what is the purpose of ruling a fumble out. Why, in the nfl, is fumbling into the endzone a touchback. Team b may accept the result of the play or next snap the ball at its 20yard line exception. If there is any question as to whether a defender is stripping or batting a ball in player possession, the officials will. Punching at the ball is actually an illegal play, according to the nfl rule book. See rule 8, section 4, articles 14 for rules applicable to illegal contact with an eligible receiver.
First of all the tuck rule was already a rule in the nfl rule book so the. Its always been a pretty arbitrary rule in the rulebook, as another poster says, it hearkens to the days of rugby. In the alliance of american football, it was an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty to propel the ball out of the field of play during a touchdown celebration. The nfl rule book says there is a penalty for illegal batting. This does not apply to a team a player who is blocked out of bounds and attempts to return inbounds immediately. Oct 06, 2015 nfl batted ball rule explainer referees conferred after seattles k.
Nfl catch rule, explained after controversy sports illustrated. Wright batted the ball out of the end zone late in the seahawkslions game monday night, but no flag was thrown. Seahawks beat lions, but refs blow call on gamesaving. For enforcement, treat as a foul during a backward pass or fumble see 87 7. Oct 06, 2015 a full breakdown of the missed batting call.
The fumble occurred at the 1 yard line and enforcement places the ball. The best nfl coaches are outsmarting the rule book. Where the word illegal appears in this rule book, it is an institutional term of art pertaining strictly to actions that violate nfl playing rules. Wright admits to intentionally batting fumble from calvin johnson after seattle safety kam chancellor knocked the ball lose in the seahawks 10 win over the detroit lions. Because the goal line is involved and this is a consistent application of the impetus rule, blandino said. Nfl loosens rules on endzone celebrations after touchdowns. The tuck rule is defined in rule 3, section 21, article 2, note 2 of the nfl official rules and is defined below.
393 1081 1518 681 245 364 965 368 1398 156 891 1533 1217 711 458 1047 257 1065 450 933 1529 934 1461 43 920 1300 871 116 1462 1240 144 790