The book is broken down into two parts, the first part contains arguments for euthanasia and. Books about physician assisted suicide and euthanasia all. It is also called physician assisted suicide, physician aidindying, and patient administered hastened death. They are intended to guide terminally ill individuals whose quality of life has shrunk to nothing. Physician assisted suicide has a unique background that has played a significant role with numerous legal and political struggles behuniak, 2011. Physicianassisted suicide an issue for nominee gorsuch cnn. June 2008 physicianassisted suicide in oregon this article draws on six cases previously published, three of them by us.
But he reserves his most scathing critique for a theologian and a patristic scholar, arthur j. There has been a 21% increase in the number of prescriptions for assisted suicide in oregon since 2009. Apr 06, 2017 neil gorsuchs views on physician assisted suicide have come under scrutiny amid a showdown over the supreme court nominees confirmation. American college of physicians reaffirms opposition to physicianassisted suicide michael j. Physicianassisted suicide is the provision to a patient by a medical health professional of the means of ending his or her own life. The case for legalizing physicianassisted dying and euthanasia. Physicianassisted suicide is not progressive the atlantic. Nov 26, 2014 read cnn s fast facts on physicianassisted suicide.
In this article, recent evidence regarding the implementation of pas. Oloughlin september 21, 2017 a woman holds up a sign during a rally against assisted suicide in 2016. Neil gorsuchs views on physicianassisted suicide have come under scrutiny amid a showdown over the supreme court nominees confirmation. Though there was certainly a moral focus in the argument in favour of euthanasia. Given the great responsibility conferred on physicians by recent laws allowing pas, a careful examination of this subject is warranted by psychiatrists and other specialists who may be consulted during a patients request for pas. Olkin, why i changed my mind about physicianassisted suicide. Allowing physicianassisted suicide pas would be a grave mistake for four reasons, as explained in a heritage foundation backgrounder, always care, never kill. Rothenburger is a veterinarian and researcher in the department of pathobiology at the ontario veterinary college in guelph, ontario editors note. As in the report of the committee on physicianassisted suicide and euthanasia suicide and lifethreatening behavior, v. Review of physicianassisted suicide edited by robert f. A good introduction to the topics of euthanasia and physicianassisted suicide. Mention the term euthanasia, and the first thing most people think of is the epic assisted suicide battle of the 1990s starring jack doctor death kevorkian. The book presents legal and moral arguments against euthanasia and assisted. Michael manning, md patilist press, malnvab, nj, 1998, 120 pp.
Charles had end stage lung disease and opted for physician assisted death. Michael mannings work, however, although well meaning, ultimately offers nothing that cannot be obtained elsewhere in clearer and occasionally more correct form. May 04, 2015 allowing physicianassisted suicide pas would be a grave mistake for four reasons, as explained in a heritage foundation backgrounder, always care, never kill. Books about physician assisted suicide and euthanasia. Pridonoff physicians should not assist in suicide anneke quinta physicianassisted suicide is moral timothy e.
He pulls no punches in criticizing kaufmans account. Sep 21, 2017 american college of physicians reaffirms opposition to physicianassisted suicide michael j. In oregon in 1994, voters approved physicianassisted suicide for some patients who are terminally ill the patients must administer the drugs. In two of the cases the information is provided by one source onlyin one case by a proponent, and in the other by an opponent, of assisted suicide. Court of appeals, ninth circuit, 1996 wl 94848 wash. Jojo moyes goodreads author shelved 99 times as assistedsuicide avg rating 4. May 22, 2002 physician assisted suicide and euthanasia are legal in the netherlands, but physicians must operate under strict conditions, including the presence of a voluntary and wellconsidered request. Physician assisted suicide is a crossdisciplinary collection of essays from philosophers, physicians, theologians, social scientists, lawyers and economists. This book is a timely and valuable contribution to the debate. So the researchers assumed the figure would be similar to that in the netherlands, where physicianassisted suicide is legal and routine.
Bennahum physicianassisted suicide is immoral daniel p. Oct 25, 2012 suicide might be a purely private act. May 16, 1998 the reason is that physician assisted suicide endows patients with greater levels of control over when and how their lives end. From the legislators perspective it seems less liable to misuse and abuse. Physician assisted suicide continues in the fine tradition of the medical ethics series published by indiana university press. As his closest relative and proxy decision maker, dick was deeply involved in caring for his brother. Jul 15, 1998 so the researchers assumed the figure would be similar to that in the netherlands, where physician assisted suicide is legal and routine. Bennahum physician assisted suicide is immoral daniel p. By comparison the arguments against euthanasia were mainly historical or practical.
Physician assisted suicide legal definition of physician. List of books and articles about assisted suicide online. Why i changed my mind about physicianassisted suicide. Physician assisted suicide an issue for supreme court. Physicianassisted suicide article pdf available in journal of the royal society of medicine 87 suppl 22suppl 22. Many people assume that physician assisted suicide is both illegal and distinguishable from the legal withholding or withdrawal of lifesustaining medical treatment at the request of the patient. For and against is a book written by three wellknown philosophers and ethicists. In four of them there was independent information from more than one source. Euthanasia and physicianassisted suicide by gerald dworkin. Experts individuals with mds, jds, phds, or equivalent advanced degrees in fields relevant to endoflife issues. The majority of doctors and nurses involved in specialist palliative care reject the legalisation of physician assisted suicide pas. Physicianassisted suicide compromises the family and.
Assisted suicide and euthanasia in the medical context, by new york state task force on life and the law html at state. Kevorkian, who claimed to have assisted in at least suicides, was released from prison in. Physician assisted suicide dates back to the ancient greek and roman empires but has only become a heavily talked about subject in the past century. University of michigan press, c1990, by anthony trollope, ed. Chapters are authored by outstanding scholars from both sides of the debate, providing a balanced, indepth exploration of physicianassisted suicide along clinical, ethical, historical, and public policy dimensions. In oregon, where physicianassisted suicide is legal, the number of assisted suicide deaths were 77 in 2012, 71 in 2011, 65 in 2010 and 59 in 2009. As in the report of the committee on physician assisted suicide and euthanasia suicide and lifethreatening behavior, v. Dec 03, 2012 physicianassisted suicide is legal in only two u. Twelve myths about physician assisted suicide and medical aid. As our national debate about assisted suicide and euthanasia continues, it would seem that a book on the subject whose author is both a physician and a priest would be extremely useful. Every suicide, and especially an assisted suicide, represents a failure of the human community to affirm the value of a persons life. The future of assisted suicide and euthanasia wikipedia.
How stanford university made a radical out of me, journal of disability policy studies, summer 2005. This list contains some do it yourself books on hastening death. Meanwhile, in 1997, the supreme court upheld state laws banning assisted suicide in most u. Pre1950 1906 first euthanasia bill drafted in ohio. He was unable to participate in any meaningful activities due to his. Pridonoff physicians should not assist in suicide anneke quinta physician assisted suicide is moral timothy e.
Legalizing physician assisted suicide does not change a crime into a medical treatment. Many people assume that physicianassisted suicide is both illegal and distinguishable from the legal withholding or withdrawal of lifesustaining medical treatment at the request of the patient. The future of assisted suicide and euthanasia is a 2006 book by neil gorsuch. Suicide and martyrdom among christians and jews in antiquity harper, 1992. Quill physician assisted suicide is a moral dilemma david a. This book discusses the moral issues of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. American college of physicians reaffirms opposition to. In 1939 the euthanasia society of america was established and advocated that it was considered humane for an individual that is considered suffering to expedite their death by means of physician. Physicianassisted suicide continues in the fine tradition of the medical ethics series published by indiana university press. Physician assisted suicide is one of the most commonly discussed ethical issues in the medical field. The case against assisted suicide for the right to endoflife care.
Physicianassisted suicide and euthanasia are legal in the netherlands, but physicians must operate under strict conditions, including the presence. Physicianassisted suicide and dementia seattle university. Frey present the case for legalization of physicianassisted suicide. Hemlocks book of selfdeliverance for the dying, national hemlock society, 1991. Kevorkian, who had been tried and acquitted repeatedly in the assisted deaths of seriously ill people, was convicted of murder in michigan in 1999 for an assisted suicide that was shown on national television. This book explores the reasons why the healthcare professionals who have the most experience of caring for dying patients should object to a change in the law. As the first book to consider the implications of the supreme court decisions in washington v. Physicianassisted suicide in the netherlands is conducted within strict guidelines that include the following requirements. The ethical issues raised by the concept of physician assisted suicide include patient autonomy, quality of life, and what it means to act in the patients best interests. Chapters are authored by outstanding scholars from both sides of the debate, providing a balanced, indepth exploration of physician assisted suicide along clinical, ethical, historical, and public policy dimensions. In oregon, where physician assisted suicide is legal, the number of assisted suicide deaths were 77 in 2012, 71 in 2011, 65 in 2010 and 59 in 2009. Heres their story charlie and francie emerick rest after a family croquet game at daughter jerilyns home in portland, ore. At one point in his illness, charles had severe shortness of breath despite maximal treatments.
As the 2012 pbs frontline documentary the suicide plan notes, there is an underground world that has added new layers of moral and legal complexity to one of the most polarizing issues in america. This book presents moral, legal and practical issues for both sides of the argument. Debate about euthanasia and pas often arises in response to a well publicised tragic case of. Physicianassisted suicide pas is one of the most provocative topics facing society today. An unbiased analysis of the ethics behind physician assisted suicide along. Jan 01, 1975 a good introduction to the topics of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. The reason is that physician assisted suicide endows patients with greater levels of control over when and how their lives end. Supreme court is currently examining physicianassisted suicide in the case of compassion in dying v.
693 104 1547 219 629 1062 36 1423 68 534 588 420 959 747 347 1148 368 1428 1268 231 1428 254 1377 1211 101 887 470 614 1441 120 985 1477 1162 598 673 1275 888 1240 1085 767 1291 851 1060